Islamic Web Library

An Islamic Resource Center

http://www.islamicweblibrary.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/divine-books.jpg

As to the thief, Male or female, cut off his or her hands: a punishment by way of example, from Allah, for their crime: and Allah is Exalted in power.

Muhammad Asad writes,

The extreme severity of this Qur’anic punishment can be understood only if one bears in
mind the fundamental principle of Islamic Law that no duty (taklif) is ever imposed on man
without his being granted a corresponding right (haqq); and the term “duty” also comprises,
in this context, liability to punishment. Now, among the inalienable rights of every member
of the Islamic society – Muslim and non-Muslim alike – is the right to protection (in every
sense of the word) by the community as a whole. As is evident from innumerable Qur’anic
ordinances as well as the Prophet’s injunctions forthcoming from authentic Traditions, every
citizen is entitled to a share in the community’s economic resources and, thus, to the
enjoyment of social security: in other words, he or she must be assured of an equitable
standard of living commensurate with the resources at the disposal of the community. For,
although the Qur’an makes it clear that human life cannot be expressed in terms of physical
existence alone – the ultimate values of life being spiritual in nature – the believers are
not entitled to look upon spiritual truths and values as something that could be divorced
from the physical and social factors of human existence. In short, Islam envisages and
demands a society that provides not only for the spiritual needs of man, but for his bodily
and intellectual needs as well. It follows, therefore, that – in order to be truly Islamic –
a society (or state) must be so constituted that every individual, man and woman, may
enjoy that minimum of material well-being and security without which there can be no human
dignity, no real freedom and, in the last resort, no spiritual progress: for, there can
be no real happiness and strength in a society that permits some of its members to suffer
undeserved want while others have more than they need. If the whole society suffers privations
owing to circumstances beyond its control (as happened, for instance, to the Muslim community
in the early days of Islam), such shared privations may become a source of spiritual strength
and, through it, of future greatness. But if the available resources of a community are so
unevenly distributed that certain groups within it live in affluence while the majority of
the people are forced to use up all their energies in search of their daily bread, poverty
becomes the ‘most dangerous enemy of spiritual progress, and occasionally drives whole
communities away from God-consciousness and into the arms of soul-destroying materialism.
It was undoubtedly this that the Prophet had in mind when he uttered the warning words
(quoted by As-Suyuti in Al-Jami’ as-Saghir), “Poverty may well turn into a denial of the
truth (kufr).” Consequently, the social legislation of Islam aims at a state of affairs in
which every man, woman and child has (a) enough to eat and wear, (b) an adequate home,
(c) equal opportunities and facilities for education, and (d) free medical care in health
and in sickness. A corollary of these rights is the right to productive and remunerative
work while of working age and in good health, and a provision (by the community or the state)
of adequate nourishment, shelter, etc. in cases of disability resulting from illness, widowhood,
enforced unemployment, old age, or under-age. As already mentioned, the communal obligation
to create such a comprehensive social security scheme has been laid down in many Qur’anic
verses, and has been amplified and explained by a great number of the Prophet’s commandments.
It was the second Caliph, ‘Umar ibn al-Khattab, who began to translate these ordinances into
a concrete administrative scheme (see Ibn Sad , Tabaqat III/1, 213-217); but after his
premature death, his successors had neither the vision nor the statesmanship to continue
his unfinished work.

It is against the background of this social security scheme envisaged by Islam that the
Qur’an imposes the severe sentence of hand-cutting as a deterrent punishment for robbery.
Since, under the circumstances outlined above, “temptation” cannot be admitted as a justifiable
excuse, and since, in the last resort, the entire socio-economic system of Islam is based
on the faith of its adherents, its balance is extremely delicate and in need of constant,
strictly-enforced protection. In a community in which everyone is assured of full security
and social justice, any attempt on the part of an individual to achieve an easy, unjustified
gain at the expense of other members of the community must be considered an attack against
the system as a whole, and must be punished as such: and, therefore, the above ordinance which
lays down that the hand of the thief shall be cut off. One must, however, always bear in mind
the principle mentioned at the beginning of this note: namely, the absolute interdependence
between man’s rights and corresponding duties (including liability to punishment). In a
community or state which neglects or is unable to provide complete social security for all
its members, the temptation to enrich oneself by illegal means often becomes irresistible –
and, consequently, theft cannot and should not be punished as severely as it should be
punished in a state in which social security is a reality in the full sense of the word. If
the society is unable to fulfil its duties with regard to every one of its members, it has
no right to invoke the full sanction of criminal law (hadd) against the individual transgressor,
but must confine itself to milder forms of administrative punishment. (It was in correct
appreciation of this principle that the great Caliph ‘Umar waived the hadd of hand-cutting
in a period of famine which afflicted Arabia during his reign.) To sum up, one may safely
conclude that the cutting-off of a hand in punishment for theft is applicable only within
the context of an already-existing, fully functioning social security scheme, and in no
other circumstances.

References:

Asad, Muhammad (1980). The Message of the Quran. http://www.islamicweblibrary.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/55877864-54484011-Message-of-Quran-Muhammad-Asad-Islam-Translation.pdf

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.